Budget day
At 10:40 this morning, it was announced that “EU finance ministers have formally approved the €85bn rescue package for Ireland along with its terms and conditions”. Brace yourself for a shitstorm, Ireland. And to the rest of Europe I say… “witness your future”.
It’s starting to look like a fait accompli. Barring either a popular revolution or a massive swing to the left parties (Sinn Féin or The United Left Alliance) in the New Year election, the Irish people are to be saddled with a huge debt they did not run up.
It’s like a nightmare from the 1980s. Like nobody’s learnt the lessons of the failed IMF interventions, the Long Depressions and deprivation, the political extremism and social fragmentation. Imposing these kinds of policies in the face of an ongoing global recession is utter madness. I’ve heard all the conspiracy theories about why the institutions of global capitalism would want to provoke this kind of economic collapse… but none of them convince me. They require too much vision from people we know have none. They require a level of organisation from the political elite that their overt incompetence precludes.
Later this afternoon, the government will reveal what is widely expected to be the most draconian budget in the history of the nation. The minimum wage will be slashed by almost 15%, welfare payments will be cut to the bone and the public sector is likely to be gutted. Meanwhile individual taxation will rise, but tax on corporate profits will not. Beyond that, what few state assets that were not privatised during the boom years will be flogged off — probably to the same international financial institutions that created the massive debt now being transferred to the Irish taxpayer.
And it’s all so bloody unnecessary. Yes, the Irish government needs to balance the books. We are spending more than we’re earning and that’s unsustainable. But the idea that the best way to balance the books is to dump a hundred billion euro of private debt onto the state is beyond insane (and there are sensible people suggesting the 85 billion could turn into as much as 220 billion before this whole thing is over). It’s free market ideology run riot.
And what’s more, it’s clearly not going to work. Ireland couldn’t generate that sort of income even in a global environment of massive economic growth. So, with the spectre of energy shortages looming ever closer and the consequent global depression, we’re out of the realm of extreme optimism and into sheer delusion.
Which is why the “bail out” and today’s savage budget are unnecessary. Ireland will default on this debt. Anyone who suggests otherwise (I’m looking at you, The Government) is a blithering idiot. We will default on the debt the markets have saddled us with, and possibly withdraw from the single currency.
The only choice we have is the manner in which we do this. We can do it now while we still have some assets and a cash reserve. Or we can delay it for a few years by delivering those remaining assets into the hands of global capitalism. Our leaders have chosen the second option and have thereby guaranteed themselves a place in history alongside Quisling, Pétain and other collaborators with external tyrants. The conditions of the bail out, for example, include transferring our last remaining cash reserve — the national pension reserve fund — into the banks, so that the banks can repay the bondholders. It’s criminal, and those responsible will not fare well in the long term.
I’ll write some more about this over the next couple of days once I’ve heard the budget and digested the implications.
Let me conclude with a short video. Although it’s a speech from a US senator and deals specifically with US policy, it resonates far beyond. And it should be required viewing for those about to open our doors to the rapacious hyenas of international finance.
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Bosca, JimBliss. JimBliss said: on The Quiet Road: 'Budget day' — http://bit.ly/f4UL6f — Yet more thoughts on the Irish crisis #bailout #imf #budget11 […]
December 7th, 2010 | 1:39pm
by Tweets that mention Budget day (The Quiet Road) -- Topsy.com
“It’s free market ideology run riot.”
No, that’s the one thing it isn’t. Free markets, free market ideology, recognises the practical reality of bankruptcy. Debts which are simply too large to be payable.
Thus while defaults, haircuts, bond rearrangements and all the rest are not usually desirable, they are at times more desirable than the alternatives: such as Eire is being plunged into now.
Yes, default is almost certainly going to happen: it wouldn’t have had to if the State had not guaranteed all of the banks (as opposed to guaranteeing just the deposits, as they did anyway….it’s the extension of the guarantee to the bondholders which has been the problem) and you’re right, default now is better than inevitable default after everything has been sold off.
My only fault with your analysis is that, as I say, what’s going on now isn’t free market ideology. That ideology contains as part of its essence “you know, this is a right fuck up. OK, let’s scrub it all out and start again.”
Which is why free market ideologues like myself think Iceland did the right thing and why Iceland is going to be a great deal better off than Eire in the coming years.
What is going on at present in Eire is a corporatist ideology: but that’s not a synonym for free market, far from it.
December 7th, 2010 | 2:06pm
by Tim Worstall
My only fault with your analysis is that, as I say, what’s going on now isn’t free market ideology.
I understand the point you’re making, Tim, and I’d even agree with it were we discussing an abstract hypothetical. But in practical terms — in a world where people regularly describe the policies of the Soviet empire as “socialism” — I’m forced to disagree.
What we are seeing in Ireland is a power grab. International financial institutions (“The Market”) are — with the willing complicity of free market ideologues in our government — making a play for assets that still remain in public ownership. The terms and conditions of this “bail out” are being set by the IMF deliberately to open up to market forces those areas of Irish society previously protected from them.
The result will be disastrous for the Irish people, though The Market will be insulated from some of the losses previously racked up by the bondholders.
The mechanism being employed may not be consistent with free market principles (I grant you that). But it is being done for the benefit of the market, even at the expense of the people of Ireland.
It seems to me that as soon as The Market ceases serving the needs of the people, it should be resisted to the point of dismantling it. Personally I believe The Market has never truly served the long-term needs of the people, but now that it has come in conflict with even the short-term needs, the time to reassess it’s worth has surely come.
December 7th, 2010 | 2:35pm
by Jim Bliss
I agree with both of you (yeah, liberal fence-sitter, etc). The difference is the market, versus The Financial Markets As Exemplified By The Big Investment Banks.
My dad, who’s a veteran stockbroker and investment advisor, but also a veteran loather of crooked market-manipulating shysters, wrote a good article about this sort of thing in 2008, with specific reference to the crash. Everything in there stands.
(sadly, the fact that the main visible reaction to that one was that idiots called him a clueless muppet who knew nothing about finance (obviously, I showed him hits and links, but comments tend to strike home more quickly) made him swear he’d never write another blog again).
Ireland’s situation now is “small place we’ll sacrifice to show we’re serious about Spain not being allowed to default”. Yes, “small place that we’ll sacrifice to show the peasants at home we’re serious” is historically relevant. I’m glad for cross-border/cross-Irish-sea relations this time round that the UK isn’t in the euro.
Of course, if Spain does default, then much as the rest of Europe will be cast into utter chaos, the pressure for Ireland not to default will disappear. Not that praying for other people’s misfortune is a good thing, or anything…
December 7th, 2010 | 3:31pm
by john b
[…] I’ve commented over here, what’s going on in Ireland isn’t “free market” in any relevant sense of […]
December 8th, 2010 | 9:01am
by Yes, quite