Patti Smith – Live in Dublin, May 2007
The house-lights go down. A huge cheer erupts from the crowd when — from the darkness of the stage — a piano starts playing some of rock’s most recognisable chords. The cheer rises in intensity when the spot-light picks out the commanding figure of Patti Smith. She sings the words: “Jesus died for somebody’s sins… but not mine…”.
And I think to myself, “it just doesn’t get any better than this”.
Patti Smith played Dublin last weekend. She’s touring the new album, Twelve, which is an album of covers. Some people have criticised her for this, but she’s unapologetic. “If anyone asks you why I’ve done a covers album”, she said during the gig, “tell them Patti said: because I wanted to!”
I haven’t actually heard Twelve yet. But Patti Smith has always been better live than on record. She’s got that thing… It… whatever It is… and It can’t be captured on a record. You have to be there to experience It. So it matters little what the critics are saying about her version of Smells Like Teen Spirit; because if you’re lucky enough to be in the same room as Patti Smith when she’s singing, you get taken to a place where the words of critics don’t mean shit.
From Gloria she went straight into Redondo Beach and I briefly thrilled at the idea that she might be playing Horses in its entirety. In the end though, she played songs from almost every album including an encore of Babelogue / Rock & Roll Nigger that rocked like the proverbial bag of bastids. So as well as some excellent covers; Soul Kitchen, Within You Without You, Gimme Shelter, Are You Experienced and a version of White Rabbit on which — to lift a line — the whole building seemed to be playing bass; we also got some rarely-heard classics… Pissing In A River from Radio Ethiopia, Beneath The Southern Cross from the under-rated Gone Again and the soaring Free Money from Horses. Of course, Because The Night got a run out as is traditional.
And like all truly great artists who’ve been around for a while, I could have put together an entire alternative set-list of songs she didn’t play, and it would have been just as good. It’s impossible for a Patti Smith gig to ever be long enough.
The venue — Vicar Street — is a nice size. Wherever you are, you’re not far from the stage and although modern health and safety regulations mean that PA-systems are never as loud as I want them to be any more, the sound was nonetheless excellent. And most importantly, the band was awesome. Lenny Kaye has been playing guitar with Patti since the very first album and it shows. In a good way. Also on guitar is Patti’s son, Jackson, who I first saw (playing Smoke on The Water) on stage at the Shepherd’s Bush Empire when he was in his early teens! Jay Dee Daugherty — one time drummer with The Church — brings a vaguely jazzy influence to the band… though make no mistake, he can rock when the need arises. And Tony Shanahan is the new bass-player and keyboardist… from the opening chords of Gloria to the pounding backing for White Rabbit, he couldn’t have been better.
If you’re dithering about whether or not to see Patti Smith on this tour, then let me urge you to grab a ticket. There are very few people in the same league when it comes to playing live. She’s still got the passion and urgency that can pick up an entire audience and carry them with her to the sublime.
Afterwards I was buzzing. Proper buzzing. I wandered the empty streets of Dublin for a full hour before I could even consider dealing with public transport. What a gig!
I saw her live by the sea in Naples a couple of summers ago; absolutely fucking brilliant, just so energetic.
May 21st, 2007 | 9:08pm
by Rob
Saw her eleven days ago at Liverpool Carling Academy – well worth the trip from Shrewsbury – having last seen her at Birmingham Odeon in 1978. Agree with all the sentiments of the Dublin review – Patti and the band were awesome; she has fantastic energy for a sixty year old – and undoubtedly her strength is in the ability to inprovise live. Sounds as though the sets were very similar, albeit Redondo Beach preceded Gloria in Liverpool. Was right at front of the stage and managed to touch her (!) when she jumped off the stage for the second time. Certainly in the top five of live acts I’ve seen…..and I’ve seen a few. Hoping it’s not 29 years before I see Patti and her band again!
May 31st, 2007 | 9:28pm
by Brian
amazing. I saw her yesterday in Brussels. Last & only time I saw her before was in 1978 🙂
Can hardly believe she’s 60. Hell, can hardly believe I am 29 years older than the first time I saw her 🙂
this was a SUPER concert. If I can, I’ll go see her in Italy in autumn.
Sounds like she pretty much plays the same songs during each gig, but in a random order. Rock’n roll nigger was the closing encore, preceded by Lou Reed’s Perfect Day 😉
June 12th, 2007 | 7:55pm
by corinne
oh man i saw her at sheffield a few days after the show you saw.
she is the most brilliant performer and you’re absolutely right about her shows never being long enough.
after the gig i also stood outside in a city ididnt know on my own for about an hour.. i wasn’t even trying to meet her i just didn’t want anythin else in my head yknow
it was quite funny as i had a pretty serious exam the next day but i didn’t want to revise and forget anything yknow so i just sort of sat there and looked at whatever pictures i managed to take haha
the whole thing is totally prophetic..
oh, and i like your blog and style of writing. =]
July 10th, 2007 | 9:17am
by martha
Nice Blog 🙂
I saw her in Oslo early this summer, and still after festivals and seeing other great bands, she still stands in mind as the best concert of the year! (and believe me – it’s been quite a few) It’s like an epiphany – when she asks are you experienced? And since I have to answer no, no I aint, there is an underlying commitment there to go out into the world and be exposed to experience. Hearing Gloria live, and a powerful “Pissing in a river”, and cool “are you experienced” with her playing her clarinet, and of course “Rock’n’Roll nigger” were energetic!
Anyways, in one of her encores she old Lou Reed’s “Perfect Day” and she dedicated it to the audience for us being such a nice kind. But by the time she reached to first chourus, we were singing so loud that she stepped back and cried – Patti Smith cried on stage – and was so moved she forgot her words. Moments like this are life changing, like an epiphany – and indeed, some experience!
The way she walks on stage, dressed like the average hobo – becomes shiny cloaks, and the scruffy hat turns into a halo because what she emits is so beautiful…man..hope I’ll be like her someday!
July 23rd, 2007 | 11:09am
by siw
[…] Culturally speaking, the best album of the year was Neon Bible by Arcade Fire (sorry to be so predictable). Other good ones… Saltbreakers by Laura Veirs, Memory Almost Full by Paul McCartney, and The Projected Passion Revue by Dexy’s Midnight Runners (a re-issue of old material, but it’s classic stuff). Oh, and check out You! Me! Dancing! by Los Campesinos! (discovering Los Campesinos! was the musical highlight of the year for me… fantastic stuff… kind of like Arcade Fire Vs. Stereolab at a Polyphonic Spree gig in Exeter… looking forward to seeing them in Dublin in February). Best gig of 2007 was Patti Smith at Vicar Street. […]
January 9th, 2008 | 1:35am
by The Quiet Road » Blog Archive » Two Thousand and Eight